As brows become sparser, finer, or lighter with age, the best eyebrow pencils for older women can make a big difference. Over time, brow hairs may also become more wiry, while the skin underneath can develop more texture—meaning the brow pencil that you’ve always used can suddenly look too harsh or be harder to apply. Luckily, our favorite formulas for mature brows come in nuanced, realistic shades (including options for gray hair) with fine tips and blendable textures that make it easier to add definition without looking drawn on.

Even though brows don’t take up much real estate, a little definition can make a surprisingly big difference. “Brows frame the shape of the face and restore contrast,” says ​Kierra Lanice Wray, a makeup artist based in Lansing, Michigan. As brow hairs lighten or thin, “you start to lose shape and definition,” she says, which can make the eyes appear less lifted.

• Best for Fully Gray Brows: Benefit Goof Proof Waterproof Easy Shape & Fill Eyebrow Pencil in Cool Grey, $28
• Best for Dark Hair Going Gray: Jones Road the Brow Pencil in Grey, $22
• Best for Salt-and-Pepper Brows: Wunderbrow Micro-Classic Easy Fill Brow Pencil in Taupe Grey, $10
• Best for Wiry/Textured Brows: Kosas Brow Pop Dual Action, $26

And if your hair has gone gray, Wray cautions against automatically reaching for the shade you used years ago. “Gray isn’t a lighter shade of brown; it’s its own color and lacks pigment,” she says. Rather than drawing on a whole new brow—which can create harsh contrast—the goal is to softly fill sparse areas and define the shape you already have. Ahead, we rounded up the best eyebrow pencils for older women to do exactly that.

Why it's worth it: Benefit Cosmetics has been in the brow game for so long that most of us have owned at least one of their pencils at some point. If your brows are entirely gray, the brand’s Goof Proof Easy Shape & Fill Pencil in Cool Grey is as universally flattering as it gets. When brows turn gray, undertone matters: too warm reads unnatural, while overly ashy can veer chalky and dull. “This cool-toned shade keeps gray brows looking natural and believable,” says Tonya Riner, a makeup artist based in Houston, Texas.

The retractable, angled tip makes shaping intuitive and eliminates the need for sharpening, so the stroke width stays consistent and harder to overdo. “Use the angled edge to fill in sparse areas, then switch to the finer point to add hair-like strokes,” she adds. The attached spoolie brush lets you comb through pigment to soften edges and blur any heavy spots for a more natural finish. And the smooth, castor-oil–based formula blends easily, then sets into long-lasting, 12-hour wear without smudging.

Why it's worth it: Choosing a pencil shade for brunettes or black hair that is starting to gray can be tricky, as warmer browns often look too red, while ashy tones can fall flat or chalky. Jones Road’s Brow Pencil adds fullness without laying down a block of heavy color. “This pencil has tiny hair-like fibers in it to create the look of full, natural brows,” says New Jersey-based makeup artist Denise Del Russo. Shea butter, castor seed oil, and plant waxes like candelilla and carnauba give the formula a smooth glide and extra softening, while the jumbo format of the pencil format makes it easier for makeup novices to create light, feathery strokes. “You can fill them in faster and more easily,” says Wray—which makes everyday shaping feel intuitive.

For the most natural-looking finish, Del Russo recommends pairing it with “a slanted brow brush and spoolie” to shape, blend, and soften the pigment so it meshes seamlessly with both darker and newly gray brow hairs.

Why it's worth it: Blonde brows transitioning to gray can lose both definition and depth, so finding a pencil that stays cool, precise, and natural becomes key. Victoria Beckham’s BabyBlade Eyebrow Pencil handles all three. “This is my favorite for blondes because the taupe is perfectly cool-toned,” says Riner. “The ultra-fine tip makes it nearly impossible to overdo it, so you always end up with a soft, natural, and flattering shape.” The long-wear formula glides on cleanly, but it also treats the brows as it fills: Camellia japonica oil delivers antioxidant-rich hydration, while rosehip seed oil brings essential fatty acids to help keep the skin and brow hairs supple. Each stroke gets you a fuller, better-defined brow that complements blonde-to-gray tones without too much warmth.

Why it's worth it: Only 1 to 2% of the world’s population has naturally red hair, which makes red brows a niche all their own, especially once gray starts to enter the picture. The undertone has to stay convincing without going brassy or flat, and it’s easy for a brow pencil to look too heavy. Anastasia Beverly Hills’ Dual-Ended Fill & Define Powder Perfect Brow Pencil in Caramel (light red) or Auburn (soft, deeper red) strikes the right balance for most redheads, says Wray. “While many people do enjoy a mechanical pencil, this traditional wooden pencil has a softer, powder-like formula to look more natural for red hair,” says Wray. “It's very beginner-friendly with a spoolie on the end to brush and blur imperfections.” Mica and plant oils help the color glide and diffuse into a believable finish.

Why it's worth it: Salt-and-pepper brows can look multidimensional and striking, but finding the right balance takes some finesse: A shade that disappears into darker hairs can look stark against silver strands, while overly matte pigment can flatten all that natural dimension. Wunderbrow’s Micro-Classic Easy Fill Brow Pencil in Taupe Grey is a cool-toned shade that complements gray and silver strands without the warmth of a traditional brown, while its “micro-fine tip keeps the finished result from looking heavy,” says Del Russo.

The formula combines lightweight emollients with carnauba wax for smooth, controlled application, while silica contributes to its silky feel. Instead of the standard spoolie on the opposite end, “it has a comb to brush through brows,” she adds—a particularly handy swap for wiry or coarse brows, since the individual teeth can separate and coax hairs into place with more precision.

Why it's worth it: Aging often shifts the texture of brow hair, making it coarser and more wiry. “For mature clients, I find that the softer and creamier to medium-firmness of Kosas’ Brow Pop Dual Action works well,” says Del Russo. “It doesn’t require a lot of pressure when applying, glides on smoothly, and doesn’t smudge or smear.”

The slim tip lets you sketch precise, hair-like strokes around coarser strands, while nourishing jojoba oil, hydrogenated castor oil, and panthenol give the formula a smoothness that’s especially helpful on mature skin. Del Russo’s finishing touch for especially unruly brows: Sweep a tinted brow gel like the Kosas Air Brow Tinted Gel over top to hold hairs in place and add fullness.

Why it's worth it: The fewer brow hairs you have to work with, the more every pencil stroke counts—and a precise tip makes creating natural-looking fullness and definition much easier. Glossier’s Boy Brow Arch has a pointed edge for sketching fine, hair-like flicks into sparse spots, while the flat edge shades larger gaps with ease. “The rich, pomade texture also helps the brows appear fuller and stay in place,” says Del Russo, while coconut-derived emollients give the formula enough creaminess to glide on without a heavy hand.

And if thinning goes beyond a few scattered gaps? Staying power becomes even more important. “If I find myself having to completely draw in a faux brow because the brows are so sparse, a water-resistant, smudge-proof brow product like this is best,” Del Russo says, since you don’t want all that carefully placed definition sliding around.

Enter your best brow era:

• 6 Best Eyebrow Pens for Creating a Microblading Effect
• The Best Eyebrow Growth Serums for Fuller, Fluffier Brows
• 9 Best Brow Gels for Gray Hair to Tint and Nourish Your Arches

Now, watch our favorite stars break down their iconic beauty looks:

Shop all of our latest obsessions in one place! And don't forget to follow Allure on Instagram and TikTok, or subscribe to our newsletter to stay up to date on all things beauty.