Вход на сайт

Просмотр новости

Найдите то, что Вас интересует

Radiation in classical and quantum mechanics

Дата публикации: 15-08-2026 00:08:47



Основное содержимое страницы с новостью.

In classical electrodynamics, acceleration of charge generates radiation. In quantum mechanics, radiation is generated by transition of charge from higher quantum lever to lower. Is any relationship between the inter-level transition and acceleration?
Also, how about the radiation of a charge accelerated in a uniform electric field, which there are not stationary states. How to obtain frequency of the radiated light?

Discussion

hokhani said:

Is any relationship between the inter-level transition and acceleration?

Both cases have a time-varying dipole moment.

Science Advisor

Gold Member

I suppose in a simple way that if we accelerate a charge using an alternating electric field, the radiated energy will, as always, be in quanta and the energy of each of these quanta will depend on the frequency of the alternating field.

tech99 said:

I suppose in a simple way that if we accelerate a charge using an alternating electric field, the radiated energy will, as always, be in quanta and the energy of each of these quanta will depend on the frequency of the alternating field.

As far as I know, in QM an alternating electric field sets Floquet levels with energy spacing ##\hbar \omega##. But I don't know what would happen for electron.

Dale said:

Both cases have a time-varying dipole moment.

From classical view, even in a stationary state of an atom electrons have acceleration and they must radiate.

hokhani said:

From classical view, even in a stationary state of an atom electrons have acceleration and they must radiate.

Which is why the classical view is wrong.

Dale said:

Which is why the classical view is wrong.

Ok, but do you mean that charge acceleration doesn't generate radiation? Then, what is the classical reason of radiation?

hokhani said:

Then, what is the classical reason of radiation?

I already answered this: a changing dipole moment.

hokhani said:

Ok, but do you mean that charge acceleration doesn't generate radiation?

Whenever charge acceleration produces a changing dipole moment then it generates radiation.

hokhani said:

what is the classical reason of radiation?

There is no "classical reason" vs. "quantum reason". You are confusing models with reality. Reality is just radiation. The classical model has a more limited domain of validity for making correct predictions about radiation than the quantum model, but both of them are models, not reality.

PeterDonis said:

There is no "classical reason" vs. "quantum reason". You are confusing models with reality. Reality is just radiation.

In the classical model there is radiation. And in the quantum model there is also radiation. So there is a classical reason and a quantum reason for radiation, ie the reason that radiation happens in each of the models.

Схожие новости

#Наименование новостиТональностьИнформативностьДата публикации
1Are classical optics and quantum mechanics double slit experiments fundamentally the same?01015-08-2026
2Particle vs Wave Interpretations of QM01013-08-2026
3Relativity, time, and quantum mechanics0527-02-2026
4zur Problematik der Interpretation der Quantenmechanik0526-06-2026
5Building intuition for waves (& quantum waves)06.9415-08-2026
6Klein Paradox: Momentum in the Classically Forbidden Region01010-08-2026
7Measurement and expectation value01015-08-2026
8Photons vs Gravitons01006-08-2026
9How valid is the indivisible interpretation of quantum mechanics?0511-07-2026
10Explanation requested for a relativistic scenario wherein two seemingly valid measurement procedures lead to different results for the same observable0518-05-2026

Классификация: . Схожих патентов: 0. Схожих новостей: 10. Тональность: 0. Информативность: 10. Источник: www.physicsforums.com.